Scaling Balanced Energy Protein (BEP) Supplements Through Market Testing

A market test aimed to expand access to affordable nutrition supplements for pregnant and lactating women in Pakistan.

Overview

Balanced Energy Protein (BEP) supplements are recommended for undernourished pregnant and lactating women (PLW), but in Pakistan public provision reaches only the poorest households. With funding from the Gates Foundation, CERP and Mathematica co-led Monitoring, Learning and Evaluation for a market test of a new BEP supplement, Wellma, from March 2022 to December 2023. The test ran in Sindh and Punjab and compared two business models. In the rural model, community resource persons (CRPs) sold Wellma door to door at a subsidised price. In the urban model, healthcare providers and pharmacies sold it at a price set to be commercially viable.

Tools and Methods Used

The market test moved through three stages: proof of concept, refinement and scaling. In the first stage, a paper-based monitoring system and dashboard informed fortnightly strategy meetings. CERP used a mix of methods: a rapid survey of 400 PLW, a four-round qualitative study, and a large-sample survey of more than 2,000 PLW and 2,000 households. A study of over 700 women used conjoint analysis on the Conjointly platform to measure willingness to pay.

Impact Achieved

The market test identified affordability as a major barrier to sustained supplement use and informed business model refinements. Price was the main barrier to buying Wellma and to continued use. Most women were willing to pay PKR 50 per sachet, and product format made little difference to their choices. 95% percent of repeat buyers reported better energy or health.